Status
Call number
Series
Collection
Publication
Description
Fiction. Mystery. Thriller. Historical Fiction. HTML:NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER � Flavia de Luce��part Harriet the Spy, part Violet Baudelaire from Lemony Snicket�s A Series of Unfortunate Events� (The New York Times Book Review)�takes her remarkable sleuthing prowess to the unexpectedly unsavory world of Canadian boarding schools in this captivating mystery. Banished! is how twelve-year-old Flavia de Luce laments her predicament, when her father and Aunt Felicity ship her off to Miss Bodycote�s Female Academy, the boarding school that her mother, Harriet, once attended across the sea in Canada. The sun has not yet risen on Flavia�s first day in captivity when a gift lands at her feet. Flavia being Flavia, a budding chemist and sleuth, that gift is a charred and mummified body, which tumbles out of a bedroom chimney. Now, while attending classes, making friends (and enemies), and assessing the school�s stern headmistress and faculty (one of whom is an acquitted murderess), Flavia is on the hunt for the victim�s identity and time of death, as well as suspects, motives, and means. Rumors swirl that Miss Bodycote�s is haunted, and that several girls have disappeared without a trace. When it comes to solving multiple mysteries, Flavia is up to the task�but her true destiny has yet to be revealed. Praise for As Chimney Sweepers Come to Dust �Flavia de Luce [is] perhaps contemporary crime fiction�s most original character�to say she is Pippi Longstocking with a Ph.D. in chemistry (speciality: poisons) barely begins to describe her.��Maclean�s �Another treat for readers of all ages . . . [As Chimney Sweepers Come to Dust] maintains the high standards Bradley set from the start.��Booklist �Exceptional . . . [The] intriguing setup only gets better, and Bradley makes Miss Bodycote�s a suitably Gothic setting for Flavia�s sleuthing. Through it all, her morbid narrative voice continues to charm.��Publishers Weekly (starred review) �Even after all these years, Flavia de Luce is still the world�s greatest adolescent British chemist/busybody/sleuth.��The Seattle Times �Plot twists come faster than Canadian snowfall. . . . Bradley�s sense of observation is as keen as gung-ho scientist Flavia�s. . . . The results so far are seven sparkling Flavia de Luce mysteries.��Library Journal.… (more)
User reviews
I have read all of the books in this series, but was disappointed with this one.
In some ways, the entire purpose of Flavia’s time at the school seems to be to remove her from her home where everything and everyone is familiar. When she arrives she knows no one, and one of the rules of the school makes it difficult to get to know people: “It had been made quite clear to me that one must not, under any circumstances, ask questions of any girl at Miss Bodycote’s about herself, or about any other girl.” Is the experience a test to see how she will manage in an alien environment in which she is repeatedly told to trust no one? Flavia realizes that what she would like to do is “’To become famous in my own way.’ . . . I did not want to be Harriet. I wanted to be myself. Flavia de Luce. Full stop.” Is her time at the school intended to give her an opportunity to be herself?
The characters who reside at Buckshaw are missing in this book. Instead, many new characters are introduced, primarily students and faculty of the academy. The problem is that these characters are not developed in any depth, so keeping track of who is who is difficult. The reader is left, like Flavia, feeling homesick for Bishop’s Lacey.
There are problems with the plot, problems that aren’t properly addressed. The mummified body was in the chimney for quite some time, but it was never discovered even though fires were lit to heat the room? Is it logical that someone can disguise herself so well that not even her own sister recognizes her? There are so many unanswered questions. Perhaps much will be explained in the eighth book?
What I did enjoy is the writing style. The figurative language is wonderful: “[She] unfolded herself from the machine like a stork from an eggshell. . . She was wrapped in a dress of turquoise silk, with a matching scarf on her head and far too much magenta lipstick on her mouth. Need I say more?” and “Her voice was as sharp as elderly cheese.”
Though I did not enjoy this book as much as the others in the series, I know I will read the next one, if only to find out if the purpose of this Canadian interlude will be made clearer. I would definitely not recommend that anyone read this mystery if he/she has not read the earlier books.
Let's say ¾ of a pail. Flavia, herself, was as enjoyable as ever but I missed her interactions with her father, Dogger, Feely & Daffy and the rest of the inhabitants of Bishop's Lacey. The relationships with the students and teachers at Miss Bodycote's Female Academy simply weren't as rich.
(Minor Spoiler)
Moreover, since most of them aren't to continue and we barely met the ones that might do so, the pro forma nature of these interactions came across as marking time with the reader rather than the productive introduction of new cast members. I do hope that the next book brings us back on track.
If you like Flavia's stories and plan to continue with the series, you'll need to read this one but it's the least of the six full-length volumes written so far, in my opinion.
I'm not exactly sure what this was supposed to add to the series except for to serve as a reminder of just how much I loved the secondary characters
None of the secondary characters were interesting enough for me to care about them. I really thought that Mrs. Bannerman was going to be a stand out but she fell just as flat as the other characters. I just couldn't take all their secrecy and once the big reveal happened at the end I didn't feel that all that secrecy was called for. I am extremely happy with where Flavia was headed at the end. Quite frankly this pales in comparison to the other books in the series and is my least favorite (if you couldn't already tell from this review). Here's to hoping that the series gets the same magic back that I loved from the previous books.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the galley.
Another devilishly fun mystery with my favorite little scamp, Flavia. This time the little imp heads to Canada and hijinks ensue.
Addition of new delightfully unusual secondary characters
Especially loved all the familiar mentions of Toronto places.
Plenty or red herrings in trying
Little imp is growing up - but not to fast thank god
The setting of the school was positively brilliant and a perfect place for that little minx Flavia - this could lead to so many more stories than Bishop's Lacey
Love her inner monologues
Plenty of dark humour and smart dialogue
I've said it before I wish these books were around when I was growing up as they make chemistry sound totally fascinating - could have made a difference in this girls disinterest with science in school. Damn Flavia would be an awesome teacher
The Not So Good Stuff
A tad disappointed at the ending (but cannot tell you why as it would be a major spoilers)
I did miss my favorites from Bishops Lacey
Some things did not add up
Favorite Quotes/Passages (As usual with Bradley, I cannot choose only 3)
"I could succeed at whatever I chose. I could, for instance, become an undertaker. Or a pathologist. A detective, a gravedigger, a tombstone maker, or even the world's greatest murderer.
Suddenly the world was my oyster--even if it was a dead one.”
“I was proud of my strategy. It was one I had been saving for just such an occasion as this. Who can say no to a personal matter? Even God is curious about such things, which is why He listens to our prayers.”
One of the things I dread about becoming an adult is that sooner or later you begin letting sentimentality get in the way of simple logic. False feelings are allowed to clog the works like raw honey poured into the tiny wheels of a fine timepiece.”
"By the end of the third shelf I had begun to see why librarians are sometimes able to achieve such pinnacles of crankiness: It's because they are in agony. If only publishers could be persuaded, I though, to stamp all book tiles horizontally instead of vertically, a great deal of unpleasantness could be avoided all round. Chiropractors and opticians would be out of business, librarians cheerier, and the world would be a better place."
4.5 Dewey's
I received this from Random House in exchange for an honest review
There is no other word Flavia can use for her predicament in the latest in the Flavia de Luce series by author Alan Bradley. Flavia has been unceremoniously bundled up by her father and aunt and banished to the hinterlands, the far reaches of the British Empire, to attend Miss
Young Flavia is once again on the hunt for a possible killer and she soon discovers, not only many possible suspects and victims, but that Miss Bodycote’s is not what it seems; it harbours many more secrets than the one hidden in her chimney – it is a veritable treasure trove of possible malfeasance for a young smart chemist like Flavia.
As Chimney Sweepers Come to Dust is the seventh in the series and it contains all the humour, mystery, and just plain fun of the previous books. The new characters may be unfamiliar but they are just as eccentric and entertaining as those from past entries in the series. Flavia is at her indomitable best as a stranger in a strange land - she solves not one but several mysteries while braving the shoals of this far-off corner of the globe, attending classes, trying, admittedly mostly unsuccessfully, to make friends, interrogating suspects, and suffering the pangs of homesickness. Being away from home allows Flavia to grow as a character. As in the previous books, the mystery is tied up neatly and there are hints at a new phase in Flavia’s future endeavours as our young heroine continues to solve mysteries while stealing the hearts of readers both young and old everywhere.
I was worried that the series might be heading in a different direction. My fears were needless. The Flavia I've grown to love in her Buckshaw chemical laboratory is the same Flavia in Toronto. The boarding school setting allows Flavia to test the skills she has acquired in her prior investigations, and it provides her with a new set of people with whom to match wits. Flavia hasn't forgotten her family and friends in Bishop's Lacey. I'm not sure who misses them more – Flavia or me. I hope there's a happy reunion in store.
This review is based on an electronic advance reading copy provided by the publisher through NetGalley.
The Publisher Says: Hard on the heels of the return of her mother’s body from the frozen reaches of the Himalayas, Flavia, for her indiscretions, is banished from her home at Buckshaw and shipped across the ocean to Miss Bodycote’s Female Academy in Toronto, her mother’s
No sooner does she arrive, however, than a body comes crashing down out of the chimney and into her room, setting off a series of investigations into mysterious disappearances of girls from the school.
My Review: We all know by now what the deal is when we pick up a Bradley mystery: We're suspending disbelief in the premise of a school-girl who also happens to be a gifted forensic chemist, possessed of a fully stocked laboratory, and the youngest member of an astonishingly oblivious and neglectful family who leave the child alone to get on with her solving of the many murders that occur in her remote village home.
Yeah, right. Not even in postwar England (1950-ish) would a kid have that kind of freedom. But without that, the whole house of cards comes tumbling down. Where's the fun in that? Go with it. Surf on Bradley's wave and the reward is a mother of all waves keeping you sharp and alert lest you miss the wave's chicane.
It was fun, and while I'm no convert to the idea of more books set in Toronto (a flimsy drop-curtain illusion of Toronto as the setting was), I understand why we had to be there for this story to unwind. The mystery itself, not for the first time, failed to generate much suspense in me. I suppose this is a far-reaching effect of following a long-term series, since I see it setting in on almost all my fellow series fans. The difference for me, in this series' case, is that I am still charmed by the idea of a kid solving adult crimes, and satisfied by Bradley's humor and whimsy. Seven books and counting....
Upon closing the book and going to sleep I was left thinking, "What? What just happened?” I could not reconcile how he had chosen to wrap up the story. I was
So, Flavia is thrown into life at a boarding school in Canada. Relationships among the girls never develop; neither do great antagonisms, though one would expect both. The Headmistress is never fully fleshed out either, I suppose in an attempt to keep up the mysteries of The Nide. But, here Flavia is to begin her training. Shouldn’t we learn something about the mysterious society? Wait a minute…shouldn’t FLAVIA at least learn something about it?
I had difficulty understanding how three different people were involved in the dead woman’s untimely demise in two different and separate instances (at least that’s how I am understanding it). Are we to believe that no one smelled the body as it decayed? There was a murder. No one was up in arms over it. Are we expected to care about it?
Brazenose’s disappearance and her undercover return amongst her schoolmates and sister were perplexing to say the least and I still can’t figure out the reason for any of that. Are we to believe that her sister didn’t recognize her voice, her features; that no one I the busy boarding school ever happened upon her with her makeup removed?
Bradley didn't develop any of Flavia’s mother’s amazing history though he could have. A foray into her mother’s past would have given him the ability to weave an engaging story within a story. As it is, the torch was never really passed to Flavia. We are left with her feeling unusually insecure and with the thought that she will be returning to home in England. None of this fits with what I've come to expect from Bradley’s writing. I am disappointed.
Having been twelve years old for 7 books now, it's time for her to grow up a little. Moving away from her family gives her an opportunity to test her independence and she is also given a chance to learn more about the mother she never knew.
As I read this book I found she brought to mind a favorite heroine from my childhood, Eloise, who can't help but stick her nose in where it isn't wanted and is totally comfortable dealing with adults as equals.
However, no sooner does she arrive, however, than a body comes crashing down out of the chimney and into her room, setting off a series of investigations into mysterious disappearances of girls from the school. While in this new environment Flavia does learn about her mother and the work (and secret society) she eventually becomes involved with. The major disappointment of this book is that many of my favorite characters of this series were missing, Flavia’s sisters and her father, the Inspector and his wife and the always wonderful Dogger. Flavia does not seem the same without them. Not my favorite of the Flavia series—but still worth the read. 3 out of 5 stars.
But I was disappointed. I know that Flavia’s involvement in,
Flavia shines through this book, but you’ve got to love her to put up with the story.
Faithful readers have been eagerly waiting for this book - after several revelations in the last book, Flavia is on her way from England to Canada to attend Miss Bodycote's Female Academy - "where I was to be trained to assume some ancient and hereditary role of which I was still kept mostly in ignorance." (Canadians take note - it's located just off the Danforth)
But Flavia being Flavia....yes, there's a dead body involved (okay, more than one). But along with that body, there's a whole new cast of characters to meet, a new setting and Flavia's mysterious legacy to unravel. There are numerous storylines running concurrently and the reader is kept busy alongside Flavia.
Flavia's descriptions and dialogue are a constant source of delight...
"The hours trudged by with chains on their ankles."
"I must state here that I have no fear whatsoever of being in a room in the dark with a corpse. In fact, quite the contrary. The little shiver I experience is one of excitement, not of fear."
"The hands are the canaries in one's own personal coal-mine: They need to be watched carefully and obeyed. A fidget demands attention, and a full-blown not-knowing-what-to-do-with-them means 'Vamoose'!"
Flavia's curiosity, her keen observations and her disarming view of life utterly enchant me. I so wanted to be Nancy Drew growing up - having discovered Flavia, it's still great fun to imagine being a girl gumshoe.
Despite her exceptional powers of deduction, her skill with poisons and her insatiable curiosity, she is still a young girl far from home. Will she ever see her beloved bicycle Gladys again? Her chemistry lab? Her dratted sisters, taciturn father, the enigmatic Dogger and the other assorted residents of the village of Bishop's Lacey? (I too, missed them!)
As Chimney Sweepers Come to Dust was great read for me (but devoured too quickly). I'll will be eagerly waiting for the eighth book!
I love the Flavia de Luce series very much, but I couldn't help but approach this volume with trepidation. I knew Flavia would be leaving behind her beloved Buckshaw estate, her eccentric family, and her murder-filled village as she
The good news is that Bradley does an amazing job of evoking Canada and a new cast of characters in a vivid way. The murder mystery kicks off as soon as Flavia arrives at her boarding school, and things get more complicated from there. Bradley's previous books are so good that it makes it hard to live up to that standard. This one does not. I really did miss Buckshaw and everyone back in England (Dogger! Gladys!). That said, it's still a fabulous mystery novel and still much better than many other books I've read this year.
Even more, I still have faith in the series and I'm very happy with the turn of events. I'm eager to read the next book, and frustrated that it means another year of wait. Sigh.
Deposited, thanks to her convenient chaperone, the mysterious Ryerson Rainsmith and his eccentric wife Dorsey, at Miss Bodycote’s Female Academy in Toronto, Flavia is soon embroiled in murder and mayhem that is as cozy and appealing as brandy and a good cigar before an open fire — or hot chocolate and marshmallows if you prefer.
The supporting cast is as eccentric and archetypal as ever and the mystery quickly accelerates with the discovery of a mummified child wrapped in ancient swaddling and stuffed up the fireplace chimney. Flavia needs to call on all her chemistry brilliance to solve the case. The intriguing subtext of the series, the super spy network overseen by her Aunt Felicity continues to drive the arch of the narrative.
I’m left hungry for the next installment — a sure indicator of a hit series.
Flavia is a very bright young person who has taken an interest in chemistry and poisons at home, encouraged by her aunt and a faithful family retainer named Dogger. She puts her chemical knowledge and love of solving mysteries to good use at the Academy when a startling event happens in her assigned individual room when she first arrives. The reader gets a good idea of Flavia's intelligence and irreverence toward authority (within limits) of her personality.
As a mystery story, this novel is a good one with many a twist and turn as Flavia pursues clues related to a an unidentified corpse found in her room. She is only 12, however, and homesickness is an emotional distraction she keeps at bay for most of the time. This shows strength of her personality and her determination as a junior detective to tackle difficult problems. After all, Flavia thinks, everything may be just a matter of chemistry.
As Chimney Sweepers Come to Dust (title a quote from Shakespeare) is the first novel I have read in the Flavia Deluce series, but I can see it would have great appeal to young female readers and even adult mystery fans. Alan Bradley skillfully provides information about Flavia's background, so the novel can be read without prior knowledge of anything about the first 6 series novels. I believe reading it would interest readers in the character so much that they would enjoy going back in time and reading the preceding adventures. I give it my highest recommendation.
While getting to see Flavia interact with other girls her age, which is probably necessary to her growth as a character, I found I really missed her interactions with her sisters, father, Mrs Mullet and Dogger. That said her observations about the other students and teachers are point on and as usual so astute that I think I know someone just like them. And of course we learn a little chemistry along the way. Always sorry to see the last page of Alan Bradley’s magical mysteries.
Read from NetGalley
Flavia is now at a boarding school in Canada. Here the reader discovers lots of sinister and a super secret society at this school.
Some of the situations seem far
I definitely see more books judging by the ending. This seems to be just the start of a new chapter in Flavia's life. Don't expect to get answers to "pheasant sandwiches" just yet.
I highly recommend this book and all books about Flavia de Luce.
I was initially a bit anxious as Flavia has been shipped away from her family home in Bishops Lacey, Britain, to 1950's Toronto Canada. But Flavia's Toronto's
I very much enjoyed this engaging and delightful cozy mystery. And , yes, Alan Bradley to continue the series and I'll be pre - ordering my copy!
Wonderful fun for Flavia de Luce fans!
4.5 stars
I've said it before and have to say it again I thoroughly enjoy reading about Flavia's adventures. Flavia comes across as a mixture of Encyclopedia Brown, Nancy Drew, Hercule Poirot, Sherlock Holmes, and Monk all rolled up in one neat little package. Although she hasn't reached the age of puberty, Flavia has the uncanny knack of being in the right place at the right time to discover bodies and mysteries. But now Flavia is in an unknown environment without her usual support network and, as a result, isn't quite sure who to trust. She is somewhat leery of her headmistress, Miss Fawlthorne, and of her fellow students. The only teacher she seems to like is her chemistry professor, an acquitted murder suspect, Mrs. Bannerman. She doesn't like or trust the trustees that chaperoned her trip from England to Canada, the Drs. Rainsmith. Is it possible for Flavia to solve the crime of the headless corpse from the chimney with minimal clues and limited access to a lab? Can she determine what has happened to the missing girls without asking too many questions and putting herself in peril?
I found As Chimney Sweepers Come to Dust an engaging and fast-paced read. This installment in the Flavia series showed a more emotional young girl. Flavia cries in grief over the loss of her mother and feels a sense of isolation by her "banishment" to a school far, far away from home. The only contact she has from home are the occasional letters from Dogger and her cousin Undine. The lack of contact from her immediate family only adds to her sense of being forgotten and banished. The Flavia revealed in this book is more thoughtful and not as prone to retaliation or pranks. She's much more analytical in her thinking and doesn't rely upon chemistry as much as she has in the past. (Yes she still uses chemistry but in a slightly different manner.) There are a lot of questions raised and answered in As Chimney Sweepers Come to Dust, but questions still remain about the Nide, their purpose, and Flavia's role within this group. I look forward to reading more Flavia stories in the future and can't wait for her to return to England. If you want to know if Flavia solves the crimes and finds answers to the questions raised you'll have to read the book and find out for yourself.
Though she’s loath to admit it, she’s a bit homesick and is
She once again mentions that her father was in a Japanese prisoner of war camp during WWII and I couldn't help but think of the movie and book Unbroken. I can’t imagine how horrible her father’s experience must have been. No child could understand that, but it makes sense that he's more detached with his children.
More than the other Flavia books, this one lost me a bit as it tried to juggle the different cords of the plot. I felt like a few things we left unresolved. (*SPOILER* For Example: why was the body’s throat slit before it was shoved up the chimney? Why did no one recognize the missing girl, even her own sister, just because she just had a wig on? *SPOILERS OVER*)
I also felt like there were a few tangents that could have been cut to simplify things. But regardless I still loved it. I particularly enjoyed seeing Flavia interact with other clever girls her own age, who weren't her sisters! It was refreshing to get out of Bishop’s Lacey for a bit. There was also a fun nod to the Nancy Drew series.
I was a big fan of the reporter character. I thought it was hilarious that he was willing to share info with Flavia even though he didn't know her. He’d do anything to get more details! I'm glad Flavia is finally getting into her role as a spy. She's been pursuing it on her own for so long and now she can get real guidance.
BOTTOM LINE: A fun chance to see Flavia outside of her normal setting. The novel works well at moving the story forward. A must read for anyone who has read the first six books in the series.
*Jayne Entwhistle narrates the audio as she has done for the whole series and she’s just perfect.
“Pride in a parent often takes strange forms.”
“There is a mystery in silence that can never be matched by mere words. Silence is power.”
Language
Original publication date
Physical description
ISBN
Local notes
Ex-library copy.