Status
Call number
Collection
Publication
Description
"Pratchett's fantastic imagination and satirical wit are on full display." - Publishers Weekly The 31st novel in the Discworld series from beloved New York Times bestselling author Sir Terry Pratchett. This new recording is narrated by Jon Culshaw, Peter Serafinowicz (Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace), and Bill Nighy (Love Actually; Pirates of the Carribean). Once, in a gods-forsaken hellhole called Koom Valley, trolls and dwarfs met in bloody combat. Centuries later, each species still views the other with simmering animosity. Lately, the influential dwarf, Grag Hamcrusher, has been fomenting unrest among Ankh-Morpork's more diminutive citizens-a volatile situation made far worse when the pint-size provocateur is discovered bashed to death . . . with a troll club lying conveniently nearby. Commander Sam Vimes of the City Watch is aware of the importance of solving the Hamcrusher homicide without delay. (Vimes's second most-pressing responsibility, in fact, next to always being home at six p.m. sharp to read Where's My Cow? to Sam, Jr.) But more than one corpse is waiting for Vimes in the eerie, summoning darkness of a labyrinthine mine network being secretly excavated beneath Ankh-Morpork's streets. And the deadly puzzle is pulling him deep into the muck and mire of superstition, hatred, and fear-and perhaps all the way to Koom Valley itself. The Discworld novels can be read in any order but Thud! is the seventh book in the City Watch series.… (more)
User reviews
Do you need a summary of the story? Oh, alright then. Superman Vimes has to prevent a battle between the dwarves and the trolls taking place in Ankh-Morpork. The multi-species Watch plays a big role, and saves the day. Horses, sheep and hippopotamuses have their place but are subservient to a cow ... and a chicken might or might not exist.
So... I think I'm glad I re-read it. Pratchett can usually do no wrong in my eyes, and really, this one isn't a break in that pattern. Vimes is his usual glorious self, the Watch are chaotic and marvellous, and the story is full of glorious grace notes - A.E. Pessimal, the government inspector who wasn't named but initialled; Detritus bonding with a juvenile delinquent troll; Wilkins, Vimes's Jeeves-like butler with an improbably violent past; and the crowning touch, and also in other ways the core of the novel, Sam getting to know Young Sam, his baby son who must be read to every day at six o'clock (and if mountains have to be moved and major roads have to be closed in order for this to be achieved, well, so be it). It's its usually delightful self.
The one thing I would note with this one, though, is that it seems to be part of a progression. Guards! Guards! is very much a parody of generic-fantasy; then Men At Arms and Feet of Clay are police procedurals in a demented Discworld setting; Jingo and The Fifth Elephant are less about the Watch, and more about politics. Night Watch is a serious novel, with very little jokes. And this one... well, it has jokes in it again, but I get the distinct feeling that Pratchett has actually gone all the way round again, and the fantasy elements are starting to be taken seriously - the gloomy presence in this novel, the dwarfish mine-sign the Summoning Dark, is written to be explicitly creepy. It's done very well, of course. But it's interesting, that the parody of the genre is more or less gone (not that there isn't parody of other things - The Da Vinci Code is deliciously lampooned throughout), but the Watch books seem to have become a genre of their own. And that's... pleasing, I think.
In the nominally human city of Ankh Morpock guard commander Vimes is worried. Koom day is approaching, when the dwaves histoically ambushed the trolls, or
Meanwhile a painting depicting the secret of the true evnts of Koom day has been stolen. The troll King is in the city. The Watch is required to finally accept a vampire. and Sam must read to his son.
The various plots unite in Sam visiting the ancient Koom Valley and solving the ancient riddle who did ambush the others first. Does he have the acumen to make sure the right result reaches the right ears? Can he prevent Ankh Morpock from being crushed in aftermath? Does young sam ever find his cow?
The predominent theme is perhaps multiculturalism, how to integrate those of other ways of living into your society. You have to change to accept them, but do they also have to change? Pratchett's view is very obiously yes, if you live here you abide by our laws. You can keep your traditions but don't expect me to uphold them. I'm not completely sure this is a view shared by all of the muslim population in our cities, but the parallels are very clear.
Nobby's sex life once again becomes a matter of concern for the female watch officers on a ladies night out. Perhaps the underlying theme so common to all of Terry's works. Is think clearly! Don't be swayed by superficial concerns, treat everybody as you would like to be treated yourself and don't let the innocent suffer for the crimes of the instigators.
The board game Thud is also well worth playing if you've any interest in complex strategy games
A dwarf demagogue is killed and a troll is the only witness, all of this as the anniversary of the Battle of Koom Valley is approaching with tensions in Ankh-Morpork between dwarfs and trolls reaching a boiling point. After Sam Vimes learns that the murder was supposed to be hidden from him, he leaps to action to solve the murder as well as not sending both species into war. Unfortunately Vimes has to contend with a new vampire member of the Watch, an auditor, and always making it home by 6 to read to Young Sam. And then the case begins to involve mystical elements, really annoying Vimes especially as they travel to Koom Valley in pursuit of justice.
Although the overall plot was well thought out, especially concerning Vimes there were problems. The various secondary arc, the humor, and quality of writing were noticeably not up to Pratchett’s earlier standards and ranged from bad to passable.
Although Thud! isn’t the best of Pratchett’s work nor the best in the Watch series, it is still a good read for any fan.
Married to dragon breeding Lady Sybil (who has also taken up Sock Darning: She isn't very good at it, but it is the sort of thing one ought to do, as a wife), and with a young son, Sam, expecting his dad to deliver a
With Lord Vetinari pressing him to take on a Vampire as a member of his force (which doesn't go down too well with the resident Were-Wolf - or with Sam himself, for that matter) and with several of his Dwarf officers leaving, Vimes is forced to try to ease the situation as the Battle of Koom Valley anniversary approaches - and the hundred's of years of bickering (and worse) the anniversary has brought with it.
A murder in the closed world of the Dwarf Deep-Downers complicates matters, as do threats to his family.
Drug sniffing Trolls don't make matters any easier.
And why was a very large picture stolen?
On one level this is an enjoyable detective romp through (and under) the streets of Ankh-Morpork, driven by a twisting, turning plot and a cast of regular Disc World characters.
But if most detective tales are, `Who-done-its'; and Agatha Christie's Poitrot stories are, `How-done-its'; Thud is a very much a, `Why-done-it?'!
What is driving the characters to behave the way they do?
This is explored most thoroughly in Vimes himself - who is not immune from the petty prejudices of humanity and who exhibits a growing anger as the story develops.
The all too easily justified anger is the most threatening thing in the story and brings Vimes, the Trolls and the Dwarfs to the very edge of destruction.
The book is a comedy, however, and like all comedies, it leaves the reader with a satisfying optimism.
On Disc-World, conflict will never be far away, but it can be resolved.
As in most of Pratchett's books, the themes and observations he makes reflect very much on the real world we find ourselves in.
Koom Valley, to me, has deep echoes of Kosovo and the `Field of Blackbird's' in 1389 - a battle which has had murderous repercussions down through history and well into our future. (Ismail Kadare's, Three Elegies For Kosovo, explores the same issues as Pratchett, but in a very different genre).
And if some of the characters in Thud are almost cliché - so too are some of the real people driving religious, gender and political intolerance (from whichever side).
For those who know the Disc-World stories, this is very much in the tradition of the earlier books - no chapters, footnotes, strong clear plot line and lovably eccentric characters (a 5 star Butler in this one, and totally `heart-of-gold, dumb-blond' pole dancer).
All in a highly entertaining tale that cannot be summarized without sounding dangerously absurd. With dwarf opera and pork futures.
For those who aren't prior fans of Terry's, please read his previous novels, which are
Is it me or
If ever the books get filmed the worse treatment would be as a form of Carry On or Hercules tongue in cheek when its about the world being true and real.
The story revolves around a historical battle between dwarves and trolls some hundred years ago in a place called Koom Valley. With the battle’s anniversary looming around the corner, both sides are getting edgier by the second. The situation worsens with the death of Hamcrusher, dwarf most prominent figure, while a used troll’s club lying conveniently at the murder scene. It may seem like a no-brainer mystery, so it is up to Ankh-Morpok City Watch Commander’s Samuel Vines ( quote: the straightest guy around but not the sharpest knife in the drawer) with his assorted band of police officers (werewolf, dwarves, trolls, humans and vampire) to prevent Ankh-Morpok from becoming the next Koom Valley.
I enjoy reading Thud! very much. It is filled with jokes, satire, interesting and colourful characters. Most of the characters are reoccurring characters from TP previous novels but it doesn’t stop new readers from enjoying it. Thus, my third plunge into TP’s world was not for naught. Can’t wait to get my hand on the rest of his novels
In this enstallment, we find Sam Vimes trying to once again bring a semblance of peace to the chaos that is Anhk-Morpork. The anniversary of Koom Valley, an historic battle between the trolls and the dwarfs, is coming up, and Vimes is doing everything he can to prevent the battle from being re-enacted in the city streets. This isn't easy, especially since a respected dwarf leader has turned up dead, and it looks like a troll may be the culprit. Equally important, Vimes needs to be sure he's home every night to read to Young Sam from The Book, aka Where is My Cow?.