Status
Call number
Genres
Collection
Publication
Description
"When Myriam, a French-Moroccan lawyer, decides to return to work after having children, she and her husband look for the perfect nanny for their two young children. They never dreamed they would find Louise: a quiet, polite, devoted woman who sings to the children, cleans the family's chic apartment in Paris's upscale tenth arrondissement, stays late without complaint, and hosts enviable kiddie parties. But as the couple and the nanny become more dependent on one another, jealousy, resentment, and suspicions mount, shattering the idyllic tableau. Building tension with every page, The Perfect Nanny is a compulsive, riveting, bravely observed exploration of power, class, race, domesticity, and motherhood--and the American debut of an immensely talented writer"--… (more)
Media reviews
User reviews
Paul and Myriam hired Louise, the
This is not really a thriller, although its premise is probably every parent's nightmare. From personal experience (long ago) I know how difficult it is to leave your baby with someone who is basically a stranger. And since the fears this book evokes are so universal, I'm guessing that is why it has garnered so much praise. The fact that every parent can relate to a story about children being harmed by their caretaker does not, however, does not turn this into a good book.
I somehow was never able to buy Louise's final actions. They were illogical, did not seem to naturally evolve over time, and did not seem characteristic of what we know of her. She had issues, and Paul and Myriam sometimes took advantage of her and underpaid her, but I'm not sure how those led to her final actions. One of the reviews on Amazon said that Louise's "transition from diligent worker to murderer wasn't all that convincing...."
2 stars
As a mother, I was very interested in the subject matter. Not only the ambiguity of motherhood but
Definitely worth reading.
But with some distance, the book rose in my esteem. For one thing, the
On the surface, this is the tale of a family who hires a nanny, Louise, when
But all is not what it seems.
Slimani is masterful at ripping off the facade, of showing what it is that truly boils under the surface of a human being, especially one in a determined role of subservience. Louise is family, but she's not. She is loved, but she's not. Louise seems perfect, but she's not. Besides the chill of what you know is coming from sentence one, there is also the chill of the way the characters treat each other, the way humans can treat each other. And then there is a scene with a chicken carcass, and that's all I'm going to say about that so as not to spoil anything, but it just might be one of the eeriest, creepiest, most haunting things I've read in a long time.
This is a quick read, not just in length, but because this is a book that will not let you put it down.
When it's time for the mother of two
There's a sense of remove to this story, with the characters remaining opaque. It is very much not a suspense novel, or even a crime novel. It's more a look at how people relate to one another, the expectations and disappointments that color how they see each other, and about loneliness.
The story has a tendency to bounce from the present to the past without warning, an often-used plot device that here
Based on the 2012 nanny-murders of Lucia and Leo Krim, the narrative is compulsive in that readers, who already know the barbaric outcome of the hiring of the nanny, are looking to understand how this could possibly have happened. The explosive beginning [“The baby is dead.”] pulls them into the story; now they’re seeking the “why’ of the murders of the children.
Louise seems to come to the Masse family [father, mother, toddler Mila, baby Adam] with more than enough child care experience; she’s efficient and the parents come to depend on her, not realizing that things are very, very wrong until the horror has played out. They miss even the most blatant of warning signs.
Tension and creepiness invade the narrative as the story unfolds, but none of the characters . . . except for the children . . . are even remotely likable and readers are likely to find it difficult to connect with them. Paul and Myriam are only tangentially involved in the parenting of their children and their situation isn’t likely to evoke much sympathy from readers.
This cashing-in on a real-life horror story revolves around paranoia and plays into every parent’s worst fears. In the telling of this tale, readers will find no wisdom has been imparted. There are no insights into parenting, no suggested remedies for the existing disproportionate cultural inequity. There’s no societal “message” for today.
As the story reaches its abrupt, less-than-satisfactory end, readers will find no suitable explanations; instead, there’s an inadequately-explained descent into madness. It’s supposed to explain it all.
It doesn’t.
Lullaby by Leila Slimani is a short but stunning psychological thriller, that will have you gripped from beginning to end. This book has also been excellently translated from French by Sam Taylor, and I do not believe anything has been lost in translation. On reading
From the opening we know that the nanny has killed one of her two charges, the other is hanging on, but only just. What follows is the story of the nanny and her descent into a psychosis via obsession and wanting total control over her charges and the parents.
Myriam, a French-Moroccan mother and lawyer decides she wants to return to work and carve out her career at the Bar. Her and Paul, her husband, must find the perfect nanny to take care of their children. When they find Louise, whose references make her second to none, a quiet and devoted nanny they give her the job.
Louise and the family become deeply dependent on each other as the weeks pass. While at the same time Louise grows more obsessive about her charges and the family they have and wishes to be more involved within it, without actually being noticed. It is from this obsession that her break down will grow from.
This is a fascinating and wonderful read as we watch the Louise’s life slowly unravel around her obsession, while at the same time being given a flavour of her life and background. This really is a clever thriller, that works on all levels.
Louise connects with the children in a way that makes caring for them effortless. She sings to them, plays games with them, and hovers over them like a doting surrogate parent. Louise goes the extra mile in her duties, by taking care of the house, staying late most nights, and cooking the family elaborate meals. Soon Miriam and Paul feel like they can’t live without Louise and Louise is beginning to feel the same. Are Miriam and Paul blinded by Louise’s charms? How far will Louise go to make this family love her?
Leila Slimani opens THE PERFECT NANNY by telling the reader exactly how the book is going to end. The revelation makes it clear that Louise isn’t quite so perfect. But what lead her to this terrible ending? THE PERFECT NANNY is the ultimate character study of a woman desperate to find her place in the world and gain the affection of those around her. Over the years Louise has faced rejection from those around her including her daughter and late husband. She now lives a life under the mask of perfection, constantly going above and beyond to prove her worth to those around her. One can only live this way for so long. This novel is not a thriller despite the shocking introduction Slimani gives readers. THE PERFECT NANNY is a slow-burning, eloquently worded trip into the mind of a woman losing control and the impacts her actions have on those around her.
But inevitably Louise has troubles of her own, troubles that she can't communicate to anyone, especially to Paul and Miriam who appreciate Louise but have no empathy at all for her as a human being. And this leads inevitably to the opening scene of the book, with the children dead and their murderer Louise, bleeding on the floor from her own failed suicide attempt
It might be the translation, but just as Paul and Miriam fail to understand or have empathy for Louise, neither does the author. The nature of her troubles are not clearly outlined - she has money worries, but its unclear exactly why or why she can't approach her employers for a pay rise. She is lonely and in need of companionship but its not clear how or why this situation came about. And its not at all clear what triggers her final crisis. The author is very good at exploring the bourgeois middle class Paul and Miriam, but for me, hasn't quite nailed who exactly Louise is
This is engrossing, but there is something missing and perhaps its better read in the original French. Its a Prix de Goncourt winner after all. Still very much recommended though
Myriam and Paul are a rather yuppie-ish couple in Paris. Professionally ambitious, but with two demanding small children, Myriam is eager to spend half her salary on childcare just to escape to
But we know from page 1 that there's a terrible ending. Slimani does a brilliant job of portraying Louise's escalating mental chaos; the growing tensions between herself and her employers.
The scary part to me is how the loving parents unknowingly invited a madwoman into their home. They were so lucky to have found The Perfect Nanny. When Myriam began to suspect there was something wrong with Louise, it was too late. The characters could be anyone, anywhere. A mother who wants to return to work, then works crazy hours. A father who works a lot but does not feel guilty because they have a wonderful Nanny taking care of the children at home. That is another thing that makes it terrifying, it could happen anywhere to anyone. A short book that I read quickly and recommend to suspense and family drama lovers.
"Her face is like a peaceful sea, its depths suspected by no one." (page 17)
Content:
Paul and Myriam live in Paris. They have two children, babyboy Adam and a little girl, Mila. Myriam, a lawyer, after a happy time as a mother, desperately wants to go back to work. When a former classmate offers her
Theme and genre:
This psychological thriller is about modern parenting, the difficult job of nannies, the complex place they have in the family they work for. This novel also shows how class and race can influence the whole life of a person.
Characters:
Myriam, happy mother of two, with the months as a housewife passing, falls into a serious depression. Back in the law firm, she works on her carrier, often overhours, and sometimes feels bad about it. She also prefers to neglect small signs that should alert her.
For Paul it was normal to earn the money for his family and their privileged upper-class life. He wants to share part of it with Louisa. For him too, Louisa is the perfect nanny and when Myriam begins to be worried, he is convinced that she just overreacts.
Louisa loves the children and wants to be needed and be part of the family.
Plot and writing style:
The book begins with telling the end, but this does not make the story less gripping. As reader you try to scan every sentence for hints, how and when things changed and led to what happened.
Leila Slimani is a captivating storyteller, switching between persons and their memories and descriptions of the life in Paris, comparing the different living conditions, while moving the plot forward.
Conclusion:
A disturbing psychological thriller about the problems of mothers reconciling job and family and the questions of every parent, if the nanny their children grow up with can really be trusted. A dark, gripping page-turner.
We know right from the first sentence that the nanny kills the children, and as expected the novel focuses on the
All in all, I expected to be glued to the pages, but instead I was more glued to looking at the last page number to see when I'd be finished.
2.5 stars - completely forgettable and disjointed.
By
Leila Slimani
What it's all about...
Louise is the perfect nanny...or is she? She works her way into the lives of Paul and Myriam and their two children...Mila and Adam. She cares for the children and cares for this family...and does much more than a nanny should.
Why I wanted to
I loved the cover of this book and I was keenly interested in Louise Louise had lots of secrets.
What made me truly enjoy this book...
I am not certain that this book was an enjoyment but it was fascinating...sort of a study in weird behaviors.
Why you should read it, too...
Readers who are interested in fascinating psycho dramas should find this book both intense and a bit strange.
“I received an advance reader’s copy from the publisher and Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review.”
Awards
Language
Original language
Original publication date
Physical description
ISBN
Similar in this library
DDC/MDS
843.92 |