Status
Call number
Publication
Description
One moment, Sir Sam Vimes is in his old patrolman form, chasing a sweet-talking psychopath across the rooftops of Ankh-Morpork. The next, he's lying naked in the street, having been sent back thirty years courtesy of a group of time-manipulating monks who won't leave well enough alone. This Discworld is a darker place that Vimes remembers too well, three decades before his title, fortune, beloved wife, and impending first child. Worse still, the murderer he's pursuing has been transported back also. Worst of all, it's the eve of a fabled street rebellion that needlessly destroyed more than a few good (and not so good) men. Sam Vimes knows his duty, and by changing history he might just save some worthwhile necks-though it could cost him his own personal future. Plus there's a chance to steer a novice watchman straight and teach him a valuable thing or three about policing, an impressionable young copper named Sam Vimes.… (more)
Media reviews
User reviews
I've heard people criticising this one as not a "real" Discworld novel, lacking in humour and the usual fantasy elements, and I will concede that in some ways it's atypical: for one thing, it's not a parody. It does share themes with, say, Les Miserables, but it doesn't parody them in the way that, say, Maskerade parodies The Phantom of the Opera. The humour definitely comes from within: from Vimes's wry sense of humour, from the History Monks (which, okay, do have an element of James-Bond parody about them) and mostly from the inherent absurdity of the People's Republic of Treacle Mine Road. So, I suppose, the humour is necesarily darker, but the fantasy - the wizards, the time travel, the dragons and magic - is still there, just, well, in the Discworld it's real, so it's taken for granted by the narrative. Like I said above, it all just fits together.
And Vimes carries it all very well, but I do like the rest of the cast. The Watch really only cameo - Carrot, Angua and Cheery appear only before the timeslip - as do the wizards. We do get to see young Nobby, young(er) Colon, and young Vetinari, who is worth the price of admission all by himself. Vimes, both young and old, is a constant presence, but the book doesn't disappear all into his head, which it might well have done in less capable hands.
In conclusion - this is the one where you might accuse Pratchett of literature. Which is a foul slander to say about an author you love, but there we go.
--J.
Sam Vimes loves being a copper, but not so much His Grace when things have to be official, but after a magical “accident” caused by the Monks of History to send him 30 years into the past Vimes must make sure history happens like it did when he was a 17-year old newbie. Becoming his mentor Sergeant John Keel and second-in-command at his old Watch House, Vimes attempts to bring about the past he remembers so his “present” remains the same. Unfortunately for Vimes, a genius yet insane killer Carcer was brought back with him and has his own agenda—chaos and murder. Add in a revolution hitting Ankh-Morpork and Vimes is in for some very stressful days.
This isn’t the first time that Pratchett has done a little time travel in a Discworld novel, but it was the first in which it was the primary element in one. Vimes becoming the heroic mentor to his younger self, is somewhat cliché but Pratchett uses Vimes own grim view of the world to an advantage as starts to become imprinted on young Sam. Yet, Vimes existential fretting about messing up his future does get tiresome after him doing it so many times in the book that it almost seems that Pratchett was finding ways to take up page space.
Night Watch is an action-packed installment in the Discworld series that Pratchett writes fantastically with Sam Vimes as the protagonist, even with the overused existential fretting. Once again I’ve found a Watch book bringing out the best of Pratchett and the entire Discworld setting, I can only hope the other two books of the subseries will be the same.
This is a somewhat atypical book. It's shorter on "Pratchett humor" and longer on "thoughtful
Sam Vimes is chasing Carcer (I always read this name as cancer, which is apt in some ways) a murderer. An unexplained discharge over the library results in both of them being transported back in time to the rule of Lord Winder - the dark old days of the Nightwatch as originally featured in Guards Guards. Vimes discovers he has to take the place of John Keel, who led the rebelion against Winder, and taught young sam vimes everything he needs to know. The original John was killed by Carcer, so he also has to deal with him at some point.
As discowrld books go, this has the highest action ratio, a fairly linear plot with few twists and some reasonable characterisation. But it's really missing the undertones. There are a few pointed comments about rebellions, and the role of police vs soldiers, but that's about it.
Enjoyable, engaging, a good backdrop to the Discworl'ds history, but much like the very early books, lacking in the depth that some of his best efforts have.
The absolute best Discworld book I've read so far. So much fabulous going on here. Vimes is at his Vimesiest, which could never be anything but wonderful, and the story has a feeling of everything that came before it being merely a lead-up to this moment.
Favourite Discworld novel. Darker than his previous work and with a Watch that is still in it's primal state. A beautiful insight in the old Ankh-Morpork.
The scene in the cemetery at the end, with Vetinari and Vimes seeing each other from both ends of time and respecting what they see--this and Jingo show the two of them so wonderfully.
This one features Sam Vimes and a slight hiccough in time which results in his travelling back in time and assuming the identity of his own mentor. Oh, and there's a murderer who's gone back with him. It's a bit of a timey-wimey twisty plot.
This time around it made a bit more sense for me as previously I hadn't read Thief of Time (which introduces the History Monks who play an important part in smoothing out the time problems affecting Vimes). Of course, you don't have to have read Thief of Time to get what's going on here, it's all made perfectly clear, but Sweeper and Qu crop up again and it certainly helps knowing exactly what they're there to do.
I think that the time travel thing was a really good way to go back and explore an earlier period of Discworld's history. I'm not really a fan of authors going back and revisiting earlier periods of their works which results in books being published out of sequence (I'm looking at you, Bernard Cornwell). I'm one of those anal people who likes to read books in sequence, where possible, and there's nothing worse that starting a series, getting about five books into it and then discovering that there's a new book been released which slots nicely in between books two and three. Then you come up against a dilemma; do you go back and read book 2a? carry on with the series and then go back when you've finished and read it at the end? not bother reading it until your next read-through of the series and then read it where it belongs?
Obviously, not all series allow the writer to go back in time. But Discworld is one of those lucky ones where it's a perfectly acceptable option and it works really well. Terry Pratchett could probably have started the book with a two sentence prologue explaining that Vimes went to Unseen University and got transported back in time and I would have happily accepted that (it wouldn't be anywhere as eloquent or as engaging as what he really wrote though so I'm glad he did it the way he did).
And it was really good to look at the characters before we got to know them; CMOT-Dibbler, Mrs. Palm, Vetinari. And I liked the way that John Keel/Vimes influenced them. It was all very clever and there were little nods to other books (and who the characters would go on to become). The only downside is that now that it's been done, it can't really be done again unless it was with a different character and in a different way, which is a shame because I'd like to know more about the young Ventinari, the young CMOT-Dibbler and the young Sam Vimes.
As I said, I love the Watch books. I especially like the later Watch books, like this one, as they were the ones I became familiar with first. This one wasn't really like the other Watch books, because it featured the Watch before they became The Watch. But there are often moments in the other Watch books when Vimes thinks back about the way that things used to be done, it's good to actually see that up close.
The one thing that I sometimes find with the Discworld books is that I occasionally get confused with the action. It's almost always around the same point in every book; about three-quarters of the way through when the various plot strands have come together and the action is starting to come to some sort of resolution. I think this is partly my own fault, mainly because I either end up reading when I should be sleeping and so struggle to follow things because I'm trying to keep my eyes open; or because I'm desperately trying to read in between other things (working, housework, catching up online, whatever) and so I have to keep stopping and starting.
Terry Pratchett has this way of not quite explaining everything until it's absolutely necessary to bring the whole story together (I'm not sure that's the best way of phrasing things). There's always a little bit that's withheld until it all comes together at the very end. And I guess sometimes I get a bit confused before it's all revealled at the end. But it never spoils the story in any way and I think most of the time it's definitely me, rather than any fault in the story.
One thing that does make me very sad, is that I'm slowly getting nearer the end of the Discworld series. I've only got two more left to actually buy now (the two most recent ones) and about nine more still to read (is it nine? It might be eight now, I've lost count). At least when I get to the end of those, I'll still have some non-Discworld books to read. I just wish there were more hours in the day to get through all of my reading material!
Oh yeah, and quotes! I've managed to narrow it down to just two favourite ones (funnily enough, neither of them actually feature Sam Vimes, all of my favourite quotes for Vimes would've required me to copy out at least half a page of the book and my book journal just wouldn't have enough room for that). Both of these ones feature a character called Mr. Swing and (slight spoiler if you haven't read the book) DEATH.
However, I would not go into Night Watch blind. It’s the sixth book following Vimes, and I think you really need to have read the others, particularly The Fifth Elephant, to follow along with Vimes character arc. Night Watch works best if you already know Vimes coming in. If you’re new to Discworld, I would point you towards Guards! Guards! to start with.
Samuel Vimes has been raised to the rank of Duke. He’s commander of the Ankh-Morpork City Watch, and he’s shaped them into a modern and powerful police force. He’s married to a woman he loves, and she’s about to give birth to their first child. He has pretty much everything he could want from life.
Then the hot pursuit of a murder over the domed library of the Unseen University, the premier institute of magic on the Disc, and a freak lightening bolt sends Vimes thirty years into the past to the eve of a fabled street rebellion.
“But here’s some advice, boy. Don’t put your trust in revolutions. They always come around again. That’s why they’re called revolutions.”
However, he’s not alone. The murderer he was chasing, Carcer, was sent back too. And Carcer’s already changed history by killing Sergeant John Keel, the man who taught Vimes everything he knows about being a good policeman. Vimes will have to step into Keel’s place to make sure that history goes according to plan.
As the street rebellion draws closer, Vimes has a choice. He can keep to the track of history and ensure his own future, or he can try desperately to save the people around him even if it costs him everything.
One thing I love about Night Watch is the cynicism surrounding war and revolutions. It strips the glory from them and shows that sometimes people die and accomplish nothing at all.
“When he was a boy he’d read books about great military campaigns, and visited the museums and looked with patriotic pride at the paintings of famous cavalry charges, last stands and glorious victories. It had come as rather a shock, when he later began to participate in some of these, to find that the painters had unaccountably left out the intestines. Perhaps they just weren’t very good at them.”
Night Watch is a book of shadows, both on the streets and within ourselves. Yet what makes it so powerful is the idea that we can resist the darkness, that we can choose to go against it.
“But…well, Reg, tomorrow the sun will come up again, and I’m pretty sure that whatever happens we won’t have found Freedom, and there won’t be a whole lot of Justice, and I’m damn sure we won’t have found Truth. But it’s just possible that I might get a hard-boiled egg.”
I would recommend Night Watch to everyone.
Originally posted on The Illustrated Page.
This is one of the best discworld books, and a great reaed. Follow Vimes Carrot and the rest as they battle crime
SPOILER plot notes: Sam is transported into his past pursuing a viscious murderer, Carcer. Carcer kills the man who was his mentor when he was a young man (John Keel), and with the help of some time-police monks, Sam steps into Keel's role and teaches himself how to be a cop. He is dropped into the past only days before an uprising in the city that would kill Keel and 6 other cops, and he makes it all happen again (but in a different way) in order to re-create a future he can return to. He catches Carcer and returns to the future with him, saves his wife's life during childbirth by finding the doctor he had worked with as Keel, becomes a father, and sees that Carcer will swing. He comes to terms with his place in life and what he has accomplished.
Awards
Language
Original publication date
Physical description
ISBN
Copy notes
Dust jacket covered in Mylar.
Water damage staining in back pages.