Status
Call number
Genres
Collection
Publication
Description
It is a summer's day in 1946. The English village of Wealding is no longer troubled by distant sirens, yet the rustling coils of barbed wire are a reminder that something, some quality of life, has evaporated. Together again after years of separation, Laura and Stephen Marshall and their daughter Victoria are forced to manage without 'those anonymous caps and aprons who lived out of sight and pulled the strings'. Their rambling garden refuses to be tamed, the house seems perceptibly to crumble. But alone on a hillside, as evening falls, Laura comes to see what it would have meant if the war had been lost, and looks to the future with a new hope and optimism. First published in 1947, this subtle, finely wrought novel presents a memorable portrait of the aftermath of war, its effect upon a marriage, charting, too, a gradual but significant change in the nature of English middle-class life.… (more)
Media reviews
User reviews
Morning dawns in the village of Wealding, and so begins One Fine Day. It's 1946, the war is finally over, and residents of Wealding and the town of Bridbury are gradually returning to some kind of "normal" life. And yet things changed dramatically during the war. There was, of course, the tragic loss of life, the young men who never returned. But there were also fundamental changes in England's social fabric, which this short novel portrays in exquisite and sometimes painful detail. Laura & Stephen Marshall are an upper middle class couple, and before the war they benefited from daily household help in the form of a cook, a maid, and a nurse to care for their daughter Victoria. Dinner magically appeared on the table every night, the house was always clean and ready for guests, and Victoria was presented to her parents before bedtime, freshly scrubbed and wearing clean pajamas. The Marshalls were shocked into a completely different lifestyle during the war, when their household help found better work at better wages ... and never returned to a life of service.
One Fine Day follows Laura Marshall through a typical day of errands and household tasks, after Stephen leaves for work and Victoria gets off to school. Laura ventures into the town to buy food. She queues at the bakery and the fishmonger, dealing with competitive customers, grumpy shopkeepers, and a shortage of their better merchandise. But this book is not about what Laura does, it's about what she thinks, and what that tells us about her changing world. Occasionally she reminisces about her youth, and the man she almost married, and we gain insight into the society in which she was raised. Through a conversation between Laura and her mother we learn that Laura's parents, who live further away from London, were able to keep their servants. Their home still reflects the golden age of British Empire. "It was like going back to another world, seen through the nostalgic lens of world catastrophe." But then Laura's errands take her to the home of some local gentry, who are no longer able to keep up their estate. They have sold it to the "National Trussed," and are in progress of moving into a flat located near the manor house. She surveys the packing and dismantlement with dismay, noting the marked contrast with poorer families who have bettered their circumstances and "bred and bred like rabbits in their dreadful cottage."
A sense of loss pervades this book. The loss of material goods and comforts serves as a symbol for the loss of Empire that was just beginning to unfold. You can see those "English ladies and gentlemen who would forever inherit the earth," who took pride in turning the world map pink, begin to falter. And yet there is also an air of hope, of accepting one's new circumstances and seeing the possibility of happiness ahead. Much of this is conveyed through Laura's sensory perceptions, as she picks fruit in her garden or rides down a lane on her bicycle. As the day draws to a close, Mollie Panter-Downes shifts the point of view to Victoria, and then Stephen, and somehow manages leaves the reader with the feeling that while their lives are irrevocably changed, everything will work out for them in the long run.
This is a brilliant book that had me laughing out loud at what are dire circumstances to this particular class of Englishman. Mrs. Prout is one last vestige of women who find themselves useful to these unfortunate people:
"It was Wednesday, one of the mornings on which Mrs. Prout came to circulate the dust a little, to chivvy grey fluff airily round the floors with a grey mop , to get down creakingly on her vast knees and scrub the kitchen. Mrs. Prout obliged several ladies in Wealding, conscious of her own value, enjoying glimpses of this household and that, sly, sardonic, given to nose tapping and enormous winks, kind, a one for whist tables and a quiet glass at the local, scornful of the floundering efforts of the gentry to remain gentry still when there wasn't nobody even to answer their doorbells, poor souls." (Page 24)
Oh my, I don't think I'll ever forget Mrs. Prout who also said, "all the trouble in this world, came from everybody knowing how to read." She is a real character. But oh so wise. In the end, Laura and Stephen have to figure out how to live in this new world to make the most of it and enjoy the life they have. And I have to wait for the delivery of my next book by Mollie Panter-Downes, Good Evening Mrs. Craven: The Wartime Stories of Mollie Panter-Downes. And I can't wait.
But every single small, insignifigent event triggers memories and longings. As Laura goes through her day she muses about life before the war when she had a cook, a housemaid, a full-time gardener, and a woman who did the cleaning. The cook died after being evacuated; the housemaid got a better job in a factory; the gardener was killed. Only her cleaning lady remained to help her try to keep the huge property in some semblance of order.
One Fine Day is sympathetic to the Lauras' of postwar England. Laura had to learn to cook on a god-awful stove where there was never any way to gauge the temperature of the oven. She shopped every day because there were no modern refrigerators. There was an endless pile of mending and cleaning. Carpets were swept, not vacuumed; flagstone floors were hard on the knees. Laura did the work of five people while she tried, without success, to keep the the prewar standards of dinner in the dining room and coffee in the sitting room.
The book is a portrait of how life had changed because of the war. Laura is gray-haired and tired. When the village Adonis looks at her, she images he sees, not the willowy beauty who had her choice of suitors, but a comfortable old sofa! Still, Laura is not one to feel sorry for herself. There is too much beauty in the over-run garden. She and her husband love each other and she has a wonderful, little girl. If there are hard times ahead, she and her family will adapt and prevail.
This sounds like it would make for a depressing plot, but it's really not. Laura is a plucky young woman, with a poetic spirit and a heart that is far more concerned with her family than her house. She feels chained to her duties as a house wife, trapped by her house which takes on a grumbling personality of its own, but she would much rather take Victoria on an impromptu vacation to the shore than think about these things. She doesn't know how to break out of the duties that have been ingrained in her as the only way of life, but her spirit constantly chafes under these rules and takes refuge in the sight of a bird or a walk through the grass. Her voice, which is the most dominant throughout the novel, is full of tenderness and weariness and bemusement at the situation embracing them now. Because she can accept these changes with a sense of humor, we can, too.
The tone of the novel reflects that of the day described, in most instances calm and comfortable, with little moments of sunlight speckling throughout. Nonetheless, the story never lags, but flows on smoothly, like a placid river. We filter everything through Laura's mind, and in a few instances, through Victoria and Stephen, so that though the events described are common place, I was never bored. I felt like I was living in this small village, turned upside down and made so different by a war that still left visible traces in the land, and even deeper scars in the people themselves. Yet the resolution of the people to carry on, to make do and adjust, was stronger than any despair, and the possibility of the future rang clear. This isn't a work that will shape the literary world, but it is a well-written period piece that shows how the world war affected life for everyone in England, how it dramatically changed the way the middle class world worked; portrayed in a manner that isn't depressing but easy to approach and to produce empathy.
Things
There’s not much “action,” as such; in fact this novel is written more as a group of character sketches. Mollie Panter-Downes writes beautifully; you can feel the breeze of a hot summer day up on Barrow Down. It’s a slow-moving, meandering book (much like the hot summer weather described in the book), and it takes a while to get into it. But once you do, this book is well worth it.
Much more so than there, though, does Panter-Downes get under the skin of the class system, its destabilization after WWII, and the sense of delusion under which most privileged Brits lived during the war. While Laura holds the center, and causes Panter-Downes to focus a lot on women's changing roles in and out of the domestic sphere, comments about class and aging, class and bias, class and hypocrisy—all combined with an attention to gender—there are some very astute portraits in here, too, of a crisis in masculinity that the war prompted more so than WWI did, a sense of displacement, and, even still, a nationalistic pride and all but unfounded optimism that is never droll, trite, or sentimental.
It's a damn shame this book is out of print; even more so, that Panter-Downes has written several other novels, about which I can find hardly any information at all, anywhere. If anyone finds information out, please do comment below. This is a fantastic writer whose insight into humanity just in the aftermath of chaos is so worthwhile and prescient to read given the current political climate.
bought in stratford.
The theme of change and adaptation is rooted in the history and permanence of the English countryside. The characters are faced with the social upheaval brought about by the war. The middle and upper classes were left to cope with their crumbling homes and lifestyles after the servants left during the war. The people who would have done the work have discovered new opportunities and freedoms beyond the confines of their former roles. We get a glimpse of the difficulties encountered by soldiers returning to families and homes that have evolved without them, and the families who likewise had to adjust to fit the men and their expectations back into their lives.
The writing is beautiful, with wonderful descriptions of the countryside and people of the village. Laura is a lighthearted and sympathetic character. While there is a sense of melancholy for what has been lost for some, there is also optimism for the future. Despite the lack of action, the book is enthralling, with a strong sense of time and space. For the modern reader, it casts a spotlight on a moment in the past. I wonder what it was like for the original readers back when the book was serialized and published in 1946-47.